Should Allowance Be Allowed

Getting paid for doing everyday tasks around the house has become the norm but shouldn’t kids do these things as part of their daily responsibilities?

I’m old school. I’m stubborn and I don’t follow trends when it comes to parenting. We don’t watch TV during the school week, we don’t sit on the computer and play mindless games and there are no hats, cell phones or bad manners at our dinner table. So when my friends started asking me how much allowance I give my elementary school aged children I laughed, out loud. Why in the world would I pay my children to do the things needed to sustain the house they live in?

I did some research on the topic and it turns out, much to my surprise that there are a host of “professionals” that believe children should be paid, for example, 50 cents per week for each year of age. In this scenario my 7-year-old would get $3.50 per week. Others have suggested a dollar per week for each year of the child, in which case my 7-year-old would receive $7.00 per week. That works out to be $364 per year for my 7-year-old. $364.00 per year for what: vacuuming, dusting, cleaning their room, taking out the trash, setting the table?

This strikes me as utterly insane. Paying a child to keep up the house they live in is in my opinion nuts. Also, if you pay a child for doing chores they may come to expect to be paid every time they clear the table or bring in the trash cans from the curb. I think these things should be a condition of living in the house. These are the things we all do to be good citizens.

So, how do children earn money and learn to become fiscally responsible? While I won’t be paying my kids to do the day-to-day chores needed to sustain a house I will consider the idea that an extra special job like cleaning out the garage, washing the car, helping Dad paint the bathroom may get some cash. I will have 2-3 of these special jobs lined up per month and will allow the kids to choose which jobs they’d like, explain the payment and when the job needs to be completed. Just like I have a deadline for my articles, the kids will have deadlines for their jobs.

In addition to these special jobs, my kids often get cash from their extended family. These two “incomes” add up and currently both kids have more money in their wallets than I do. Next comes the lesson of how we spend money. Impulse spending is very dangerous (I should know) and something kids can learn about at an early age. We make wish lists. If my kids still want something on that list after a few weeks then they can use their saved money and get it. If there is a trip coming up I remind the kids that they may want to use their money on the trip. Both kids have wallets and when the time comes, both kids will have a savings account.

Bottom line, my kids won’t get paid to do the day to day chores needed to sustain a house. They will however be taught how to be financially responsible through paid special jobs around the house. They will also be taught how to have a good work ethic by doing these jobs well and on time.

There are lots of web sites that can help. I started with www.themint.org and found some fun ideas for earning money and some teaching ideas too.  

Heather January 09, 2013 at 04:53 PM
In our home, allowance wasn't for doing the chores. It was so that the kids didn't have to rely on my whims when begging for gum, etc. and it got rid of the "gimmes" at the store. I gave my kids five dollars a week (three to spend, one for charity and one to save for long-term things like gifts to each other). They could spend the $3 on incidental things like gum, nail polish, ice cream treat, etc. But that's it. No more asking Mom. Surprisingly, they ended up saving most of the money once they realized "they" were paying for those things. It definitely solved the whining in stores. And it opened a lot of great conversations once the charity jar was full about where we were sending the money.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »